| 2013 |
| Rob Giles (Jr., K) |
All-MASCAC First Team Offense (K) |
| Josh Morgan (Sr., LB) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Defense (LB) |
| Chris Smith (Jr., KR/PR) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Offense (RET) |
|
| 2014 |
| Kyle Wilson (Sr., DL) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Defense (DL) |
| Paul Castonia |
Sportsmanship Coach of the Year |
| Sam Bellamy (Jr., DB) |
MASCAC Sportsmanship Team |
|
| 2015 |
| Brandonn Drumgole (Fr., WR) |
MASCAC Offensive Rookie of the Year |
| Ryan Bentley (Sr., OL) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Offense (G) |
| Sam Bellamy (Sr., DB) |
MASCAC Sportsmanship Team |
|
| 2016 |
| Paul Castonia |
Champion's Choice Coach of the Year |
| Prince Gbaley (Fr., DB) |
MASCAC Defensive Rookie of the Year |
| Zach Ziemba (Sr., DB) |
All-MASCAC First Team Defense (DB) |
| Brad Drewek (Sr., DL) |
All-MASCAC First Team Defense (DL) |
| Blair Zentek (Jr., DB) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Defense (DB) |
| Brandon Mitchell (Sr., DL) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Defense (DL) |
|
MASCAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Brandt O'Hara (Fr., G) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Offense (G) |
|
| 2017 |
| Paul Castonia |
Champion's Choice Coach of the Year |
| Zach Ziemba (Gr., DB) |
MASCAC Defensive Player of the Year |
|
All-MASCAC First Team Defense (DB) |
| Blair Zentek (Sr., DB) |
All-MASCAC First Team Defense (DB) |
| Joe Esposito (Sr., DL) |
All-MASCAC First Team Defense (DL) |
|
MASCAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Andrew Romeo (Jr., OL) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Offense (OT) |
| Mitch Banuskevich (Jr., RB) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Offense (RB) |
| Zack Edwards (Jr., QB) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Offense (QB) |
| Jeremy Martin (Fr., K/P) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Offense (K) |
|
All-MASCAC Second Team Defense (P) |
|
| 2018 |
| Mitch Banuskevich (Sr., DB) |
All-MASCAC First Team Defense (DB) |
|
All-MASCAC Second Team Offense (RET) |
|
MASCAC Sportsmanship Team |
| Jeremy Martin (So., P) |
All-MASCACÂ First Team Defense (P) |
|
All-MASCAC First Team Offense (K) |
| Nick Cusano (Jr., OL) |
All-MASCAC First Team Offense (G) |
| Matt Shea (Jr., DB) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Defense (DB) |
| Zac Garside (So., DL) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Defense (DL) |
| Matt Palma (Jr., OL) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Offense (OT) |
| Max Osgood (So., TE) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Offense (TE) |
|
| 2019 |
| Matt Shea (Sr., DB) |
All-MASCAC First Team Defense (DB) |
| Nick Cusano (Sr., OL) |
All-MASCAC First Team Offense (C) |
| DJ Hersom (Sr., FB) |
All-MASCAC First Team Offense (FB) |
| Brandt O'Hara (Sr., OL) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Offense (OT) |
| David Hamilton (Sr., RB) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Offense (RB) |
| Matt Tosone (Jr., DB) |
MASCAC Sportsmanship Team |
|
| 2021 |
| Bryce Wronski (Jr., LB) |
All-MASCAC First Team Defense (ILB) |
| James Mauro (Sr., OL) |
All-MASCAC First Team Offense (G) |
| Teddy Fellows (Fr., OL) |
All-MASCACÂ First Team Offense (OT) |
| Zach Caffrey (Sr., FB) |
All-MASCAC First Team Offense (FB) |
| Ryan Milliken (Sr., KR/PR) |
All-MASCAC First Team Offense (RET) |
| David Salazar (Sr., DB) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Defense (DB) |
| Bryan Warren (Jr., TE) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Offense (TE) |
| Kayden Baillargeon (Sr., DB) |
MASCAC Sportsmanship Team |
|
| 2022 |
| Braden Lynn (So., QB) |
MASCAC Offensive Rookie of the Year |
| Emmanuel Ughu (Jr., DL) |
All-MASCAC First Team Defense (DL) |
| Thanos Boulukos (Gr., FB) |
All-MASCAC First Team Offense (FB) |
| Teddy Fellows (So., OL) |
All-MASCAC First Team Offense (OT) |
| Quinn Girard (Sr., DB) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Defense (DB) |
| Evan Wilson (So., LB) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Defense (ILB) |
| James Mauro (Gr., OL) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Offense (G) |
| Bryan Warren (Sr., TE) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Offense (TE) |
| Manny Sanchez (Sr., RB) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Offense (RB) |
| Sam Flemming (Sr., DL) |
MASCAC Sportsmanship Team |
|
| 2023 |
| Willie Lombard (Jr., RB/RET) |
All-MASCAC First Team Offense (RET) |
| Collin Crowe (Sr., DL) |
MASCAC Sportsmanship Team |
|
| 2024 |
| Robbie Engel (Fr., DB) |
MASCAC Defensive Rookie of the Year |
| Willie Lombard (Sr., RB/RET) |
All-MASCAC First Team Offense (RB) |
|
All-MASCAC First Team Offense (RET) |
| Jack Claeys (So., OL) |
All-MASCAC First Team Offense (C) |
| Sean Quinn (Jr., OL) |
All-MASCAC First Team Offense (OT) |
| Evan Wilson (Sr., LB) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Defense (ILB) |
| Braden Lynn (Sr., QB) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Offense (QB) |
| Jacob Morris (So., TE) |
All-MASCAC Second Team Offense (TE) |
| Josh Crosswhite (Sr., WR) |
MASCAC Sportsmanship Team |
|
| 2025 |
| Paul Castonia |
BSN Coach of the Year |
| Sean Quinn (Sr., OL) |
MASCAC Offensive Lineman of the Year |
|
All-MASCAC First Team Offense (OT) |
| Jack Claeys (Jr., OL) |
All-MASCAC First Team Offense (C) |
| Jacob Morris (Jr., TE) |
All-MASCAC First Team Offense (TE) |
| Gregory Walker (Gr., RB) |
All-MASCAC First Team (RB) |
| Braden Lynn (Gr., QB/P) |
All-MASCAC First Team Defense (P) |
|
All-MASCAC Second Team Offense (QB) |
| Ryan Fleming (Sr., DL) |
MASCAC Sportsmanship Team |
