| 1986-87 |
| 02/24/87 - LEC Quarterfinal (at UMass Dartmouth) |
| #5 Plymouth State vs. #4 UMass Dartmouth |
L, 57-76 |
|
| 1987-88 |
| 02/23/88 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Eastern Connecticut St.) |
| #6 Plymouth State vs. #3 Eastern Connecticut St. |
L, 56-75 |
|
| 1988-89 |
| 02/21/89 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Rhode Island College) |
| #5 Plymouth State vs. #4 Rhode Island College |
L, 77-87 (OT) |
|
| 1989-90 |
| 02/20/90 - LEC Quarterfinal (at UMass Dartmouth) |
| #5 Plymouth State vs. #4 UMass Dartmouth |
W, 59-57 |
|
| 02/23/90 - LEC Semifinal (at UMass Dartmouth) |
| #5 Plymouth State vs. #1 Southern Maine |
L, 49-64 |
|
| 1990-91 |
| 02/22/91 - LEC Semifinal (at Eastern Connecticut St.) |
| #3 Southern Maine vs. #2 Plymouth State |
L, 51-74 |
1991-92
|
| 02/25/92 - LEC Quarterfinal (at UMass Dartmouth) |
| #5 Plymouth State vs. #4 UMass Dartmouth |
L, 59-64 |
|
| 1992-93 |
| 02/23/93 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Plymouth State) |
| #5 UMass Dartmouth vs. #4 Plymouth State |
L, 45-52 |
|
| 1993-94 |
| 02/22/94 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Plymouth State) |
| #6 UMass Dartmouth vs. #3 Plymouth State |
W, 77-58 |
|
| 02/25/94 - LEC Semifinal (at Western Connecticut St.) |
| #3 Plymouth State vs. #2 Southern Maine |
W, 65-64 |
|
| 02/26/94 - LEC Championship (at Western Connecticut St.) |
| #3 Plymouth State vs. #1 Western Connecticut St. |
L, 73-85 |
|
| 1994-95 |
| 02/21/95 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Plymouth State) |
| #6 UMass Dartmouth vs. #3 Plymouth State |
W, 76-64 |
|
| 02/24/95 - LEC Semifinal (at Southern Maine) |
| #3 Plymouth State vs. #2 Western Connecticut St. |
W, 76-52 |
|
| 02/25/95 - LEC Championship (at Southern Maine) |
| #3 Plymouth State vs. #1 Southern Maine |
L, 60-69 |
|
| 1995-96 |
| 02/20/96 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Plymouth State) |
| #5 Rhode Island College vs. #4 Plymouth State |
W, 75-67 |
|
| 02/23/96 - LEC Semifinal (at Southern Maine) |
| #4 Plymouth State vs. #1 Southern Maine |
L, 52-55 |
|
| 1996-97 |
| 02/25/97 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Eastern Connecticut St.) |
| #5 Plymouth State vs. #4 Eastern Connecticut St. |
L, 48-54 |
|
| 1997-98 |
| 02/24/98 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Western Connecticut St.) |
| #6 Plymouth State vs. #3 Western Connecticut St. |
L, 48-64 |
|
| 1998-99 |
| 02/23/99 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Rhode Island College) |
| #5 Plymouth State vs. #4 Rhode Island College |
L, 65-73 |
|
| 1999-00 |
| 02/22/00 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Keene State) |
| #5 Plymouth State vs. #4 Keene State |
W, 90-74 |
|
| 02/25/00 - LEC Semifinal (at Western Connecticut St.) |
| #5 Plymouth State vs. #1 Western Connecticut St. |
W, 80-66 |
|
| 02/26/00 - LEC Championship (at Western Connecticut St.) |
| #5 Plymouth State vs. #2 Southern Maine |
L, 40-87 |
|
| 2000-01 |
| 02/20/01 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Plymouth State) |
| #6 Rhode Island College vs. #3 Plymouth State |
W, 70-63 |
|
| 02/23/01 - LEC Semifinal (at Eastern Connecticut St.) |
| #3 Plymouth State vs. #2 Southern Maine |
L, 65-72 |
|
| 2001-02 |
| 02/19/02 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Plymouth State) |
| #6 Western Connecticut St. vs. #3 Plymouth State |
W, 77-59 |
|
| 02/22/02 - LEC Semifinal (at Southern Maine) |
| #3 Plymouth State vs. #2 Eastern Connecticut St. |
L, 76-82 |
|
| 2002-03 |
| 02/25/03 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Plymouth State) |
| #6 Western Connecticut St. vs. #3 Plymouth State |
W, 92-59 |
|
| 02/28/03 - LEC Semifinal (at Southern Maine) |
| #3 Plymouth State vs. #2 Eastern Connecticut St. |
W, 87-85 (OT) |
|
| 03/01/03 - LEC Championship (at Southern Maine) |
| #3 Plymouth State vs. #1 Southern Maine |
L, 64-75 |
|
| 2003-04 |
| 02/24/04 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Eastern Connecticut St.) |
| #7 Plymouth State vs. #2 Eastern Connecticut St. |
L, 51-87 |
|
| 2004-05 |
| 02/22/05 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Keene State) |
| #6 Plymouth State vs. #3 Keene State |
L, 57-68 |
|
| 2005-06 |
| 02/21/06 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Keene State) |
| #5 Plymouth State vs. #4 Keene State |
L, 64-75 |
|
| 2006-07 |
| 02/20/07 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Keene State) |
| #7 Plymouth State vs. #2 Keene State |
L, 56-72 |
|
| 2007-08 |
| 02/26/08 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Western Connecticut St.) |
| #6 Plymouth State vs. #3 Western Connecticut St. |
L, 43-64 |
|
| 2008-09 |
| 02/24/09 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Keene State) |
| #5 Plymouth State vs. #4 Keene State |
L, 50-66 |
|
| 2012-13 |
| 02/19/13 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Southern Maine) |
| #8 Plymouth State vs. #1 Southern Maine |
L, 31-63 |
|
| 2013-14 |
| 02/25/14 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Rhode Island College) |
| #8 Plymouth State vs. #1 Rhode Island College |
L, 45-56 |
|
| 2014-15 |
| 02/24/15 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Eastern Connecticut St.) |
| #8 Plymouth State vs. #1 Eastern Connecticut St. |
L, 31-63 |
|
| 2015-16 |
| 02/23/16 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Eastern Connecticut St.) |
| #8 Plymouth State vs. #1 Eastern Connecticut St. |
L, 58-68 |
|
| 2016-17 |
| 02/21/17 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Western Connecticut St.) |
| #5 Plymouth State vs. #4 Western Connecticut St. |
L, 42-59 |
|
| 2017-18 |
| 02/20/18 - LEC Quarterfinal (at UMass Boston) |
| #7 Plymouth State vs. #2 UMass Boston |
L, 63-77 |
|
| 2020-21 |
| 03/03/21 - LEC Semifinal (at Rhode Island College) |
| #4 Plymouth State vs. #1 Rhode Island College |
L, 20-72 |
|
| 2021-22 |
| 02/21/22 - LEC Play In (at Western Connecticut) |
| #9 Plymouth State vs. #8 Western Connecticut |
L, 47-55 |
|
| 2023-24 |
| 02/20/24 - LEC Quarterfinal (at Southern Maine) |
| #6 Plymouth State vs. #3 Southern Maine |
L, 55-65 |
