| 1975 |
| NCAA First Round |
| Framingham State vs. Plymouth State |
L, 2-3 (OT) |
|
| 1976 |
| NCAA First Round |
| North Adams State vs. Plymouth State |
W, 2-1 (OT) |
| |
| NCAA Second Round |
|
| Babson vs. Plymouth State |
L, 1-2 (OT) |
|
| 1977 |
| NCAA First Round |
| North Adams State vs. Plymouth State |
L, 0-3 |
|
| 1978 |
| 11/12/78 - NCAA First Round |
| Babson vs. Plymouth State |
L, 0-2 |
|
| 1980 |
| NCAA First Round |
| Brandeis vs. Plymouth State |
L, 0-2 |
|
| 1982 |
| 11/06/82 - NCAA First Round (at Babson) |
| Worcester State vs. Plymouth State |
W, 3-1 |
| |
| 11/07/82 - NCAA Second Round (at Babson) |
| Plymouth State vs. Babson |
W, 2-0 |
| |
| 11/13/82 - NCAA Third Round (at Plymouth State) |
| North Carolina-Greensboro vs. Plymouth State |
L, 1-2 |
|
| 1983 |
| NCAA First Round (at Plymouth State) |
| Brandeis vs. Plymouth State |
W, 2-0 |
| |
| NCAA Second Round (at Plymouth State) |
| Babson vs. Plymouth State |
W, 3-2 |
| |
| NCAA National Quarterfinal |
| Plymouth State vs. Union |
W, 3-1 |
| |
| NCAA National Semifinal |
| Plymouth State vs. North Carolina-Greensboro |
L, 0-1 (OT), PK |
|
| 1984 |
| 11/10/84 - NCAA First Round (at Plymouth State) |
| Brandeis vs. Plymouth State |
L, 1-2 (OT), PK |
|
| 1986 |
| 11/07/86 - NCAA First Round (at Plymouth State) |
| Clark vs. Plymouth State |
W, 2-1 |
| |
|
| 11/09/86 - NCAA Second Round (at Plymouth State) |
| Salem State vs. Plymouth State |
W, 1-0 |
| |
|
| 11/16/86 - NCAA National Quarterfinal (at Plymouth State) |
| Fredonia State vs. Plymouth State |
L, 0-1 (OT), PK 2-3 |
|
| 1987 |
| 11/08/87 - NCAA First Round |
| Clark vs. Plymouth State |
L, 1-2 (2 OT), PK 1-3 |
|
| 1988 |
| 11/04/88 - NCAA First Round (at Salem State) |
| Babson vs. Plymouth State |
W, 1-0 |
| |
| NCAA Second Round (at Salem State) |
| Plymouth State vs. Salem State |
L, 0-2 |
|
| 1989 |
| 11/03/89 - NCAA First Round |
| Salem State vs. Plymouth State |
W, 2-1 (OT), PK 4-2 |
| |
| 11/05/89 - NCAA Second Round |
| Babson vs. Plymouth State |
W, 2-0 |
| |
| 11/11/89 - NCAA National Quarterfinal (at RIT) |
| Plymouth State vs. RIT |
L, 0-2 |
|
| 1995 |
| 11/04/95 - NCAA First Round (at Williams) |
| Plymouth State vs. Williams |
L, 0-2 |
|
| 1997 |
| 11/18/97 - NCAA First Round (at Bowdoin) |
| Wheaton vs. Plymouth State |
T, 1-1 (2 OT), PK 3-1 |
| |
| 11/19/97 - NCAA Second Round (at Bowdoin) |
| Plymouth State vs. Amherst |
L, 2-3 |
|
| 1998 |
| 11/14/98 - NCAA First Round (at Plymouth State) |
| Amherst vs. Plymouth State |
W, 1-0 |
| |
| 11/15/98 - NCAA Second Round (at Plymouth State) |
| Williams vs. Plymouth State |
L, 2-3 |
|
| 2000 |
| 11/08/00 - NCAA First Round (at Plymouth State) |
| Norwich vs. Plymouth State |
W, 3-1 |
| |
| 11/11/00 - NCAA Second Round (at St. Lawrence) |
| Plymouth State vs. St. Lawrence |
L, 0-5 |
