| 2008-09 |
| 10/14/08 - LEC First Round (at Western Connecticut St.) |
| #5 Plymouth State vs. #4 Western Connecticut St. |
L, 2-5 |
|
| 2010-11 |
| 10/19/10 - LEC First Round (at Western Connecticut St.) |
| #5 Plymouth State vs. #4 Western Connecticut St. |
L, 2-5 |
|
| 2011-12 |
| 10/18/11 - LEC First Round (at Plymouth State) |
| #6 UMass Boston vs. #3 Plymouth State |
W, 5-1 |
|
| 10/22/11 - LEC Semifinal (at Salem State) |
| #3 Plymouth State vs. #2 Salem State |
L, 1-5 |
|
| 2012-13 |
| 10/16/12 - LEC First Round (at Plymouth State) |
| #5 Rhode Island College vs. #4 Plymouth State |
W, 5-2 |
|
| 10/18/12 - LEC Semifinal (at Bridgewater State) |
| #4 Plymouth State vs. #1 Bridgewater State |
L, 0-5 |
2014-15
|
| 10/28/14 - LEC Semifinal (at Plymouth State) |
| #5 UMass Dartmouth vs. #1 Plymouth State |
W, 5-0 |
|
| 10/31/14 - LEC Championship (at Plymouth State) |
| #2 Rhode Island College vs. #1 Plymouth State |
W, 5-2 |
|
| 2015-16 |
| 10/20/15 - LEC First Round (at Plymouth State) |
| #6 Worcester State vs. #3 Plymouth State |
W, 5-0 |
|
| 10/22/15 - LEC Semifinal (at Bridgewater State) |
| #3 Plymouth State vs. #2 Bridgewater State |
L, 3-5 |
|
| 2016-17 |
| 10/18/16 - LEC First Round (at Plymouth State) |
| #5 Worcester State vs. #4 Plymouth State |
L, 1-5 |
|
| 2017-18 |
| 10/17/17 - LEC First Round (at Plymouth State) |
| #5 Worcester State vs. #4 Plymouth State |
L, 2-5 |
|
| 2018-19 |
| 10/19/18 - LEC Semifinal (at Rhode Island College) |
| #3 Salem State vs. #2 Plymouth State |
W, 5-4 |
|
| 10/20/18 - LEC Championship (at Rhode Island College) |
| #2 Plymouth State vs. #1 Rhode Island College |
L, 1-5 |
|
| 2019-20 |
| 10/15/19 - LEC First Round (at Plymouth State) |
| #6 Western Connecticut St. vs. #3 Plymouth State |
W, 5-2 |
|
| 10/17/19 - LEC Semifinal (at UMass Boston) |
| #3 Plymouth State vs. #2 UMass Boston |
L, 4-5 |
|
| 2020-21 |
| 05/06/21 - LEC Semifinal (at Plymouth State) |
| #3 Castleton vs. #2 Plymouth State |
W, 5-0 |
|
| 05/09/21 - LEC Championship (at Rhode Island College) |
| #2 Plymouth State vs. #1 Rhode Island College |
L, 0-5 |
|
| 2021-22 |
| 10/19/21 - LEC First Round (at Plymouth State) |
| #6 Salem State vs. #3 Plymouth State |
W, 5-0 |
|
| 10/21/21 - LEC Semifinal (at Bridgewater State) |
| #3 Plymouth State vs. #2 Bridgewater State |
L, 1-5 |
|
| 2022-23 |
| 10/18/22 - LEC First Round (at UMass Dartmouth) |
| #5 Plymouth State vs. #4 UMass Dartmouth |
L, 3-5 |
|
| 2023-24 |
| 10/17/23 - LEC First Round (at UMass Dartmouth) |
| #5 Plymouth State vs. #4 UMass Dartmouth |
L, 0-5 |
|
| 2024-25 |
| 10/15/24 - LEC First Round (at Plymouth State) |
| #5 Salem State vs. #4 Plymouth State |
W, 5-2 |
|
| 10/17/24 - LEC Semifinal (at UMass Boston) |
| #4 Plymouth State vs. #1 UMass Boston |
L, 0-5 |
