| 1974 |
| Bob Gibson (Sr., DB) |
Kodak/AFCA First Team |
| Fred Quinlan (Jr., OL) |
NAIA |
| Bill Stumpf (Jr., LB) |
NAIA Honorable Mention |
|
| 1975 |
| Fred Quinlan (Sr., OL) |
AP Little All-America Honorable Mention |
|
| 1980 |
| Lee Richard (Jr., DB) |
SID Honorable Mention |
|
| 1982 |
| Mark Barrows (Sr., LB) |
AP Little All-America Honorable Mention |
|
Kodak/AFCA First Team |
|
SID Second Team |
| Ron Simmons (Sr., OL) |
AP Little All-America Honorable Mention |
|
SID Second Team |
| Joe Dudek (Fr., RB) |
AP Little All-America Honorable Mention |
|
SID Second Team |
| John McNulty (Sr., DL) |
AP Little All-America Honorable Mention |
|
SID Third Team |
|
| 1983 |
| Joe Dudek (So., RB) |
Kodak/AFCA First Team |
|
Pizza Hut/SID Second Team |
| Ted Moccia (Sr., OL) |
Pizza Hut/SID Honorable Mention |
|
| 1984 |
| Joe Dudek (Jr., RB) |
AP Little All-America First Team |
|
Football News First Team |
|
Kodak/AFCA First Team |
|
Pizza Hut/SID First Team |
| Ed Iodice (Sr., DB) |
Pizza Hut/SID First Team |
| Dave Watson (Jr., OL) |
Pizza Hut/SID Second Team |
| Glenn Segalla (Sr., LB) |
Pizza Hut/SID Third Team |
| John Posiviata (Sr., WR) |
Pizza Hut/SID Honorable Mention |
|
| 1985 |
| Joe Dudek (Sr., RB) |
AP Little All-America First Team |
|
Football News First Team |
|
Kodak/AFCA First Team |
|
Pizza Hut/SID First Team |
| Dave Watson (Sr., OL) |
Pizza Hut/SID First Team |
| Pat McAniff (So., LB) |
Pizza Hut/SID Third Team |
|
| 1986 |
| John Sullivan (Jr., DB) |
Football News Second Team |
|
Pizza Hut/SID Honorable Mention |
| Bob Mudge (Sr., DB) |
Pizza Hut/SID Honorable Mention |
|
| 1988 |
| Matt Jozokos (So., QB) |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette Second Team |
|
Pizza Hut/SID Third Team |
| Pat McAniff (Sr., LB) |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette Third Team |
|
Pizza Hut/SID First Team |
| Steve Tirrell (Sr., DL) |
Pizza Hut/SID Third Team |
| Craig Burns (Sr., DB) |
Pizza Hut/SID Third Team |
|
| 1989 |
| Matt Jozokos (Jr., QB) |
Pizza Hut/SID Honorable Mention |
| Paul Belanger (Sr., WR) |
Pizza Hut/SID Honorable Mention |
|
| 1991 |
| Scott Allen (Sr., LB) |
Champion USA/SID First Team |
| Steve Krasinski (Sr., DL) |
Champion USA/SID Honorable Mention |
|
| 1994 |
| Colby Compton (Jr., LB) |
AP Little All-America Second Team |
|
Football News First Team |
|
SID First Team |
|
| 1995 |
| Colby Compton (Sr., LB) |
AP Little All-America Third Team |
|
Kodak/AFCA First Team |
|
Hewlett-Packard/SID Second Team |
| Jeff Ziegler (Jr., OL) |
Hewlett-Packard/SID Third Team |
|
| 1997 |
| Dave Gibson (Sr., LB) |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette Third Team |
|
Hewlett-Packard/SID Third Team |
|
| 1999 |
| Colt Meredith (Sr., DB) |
Hewlett-Packard/SID Honorable Mention |
|
| 2001 |
| John Walters (Sr., TE) |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette Third Team |
|
Hewlett-Packard/SID Third Team |
|
| 2009 |
| Zac Duval (Sr., OL) |
D3football.com Honorable Mention |
